Headline Statistics

There are a total of 8764 papers included in this study.

There are a total of 15 conferences with 3258 papers and 17 journals with 5506 articles covered in the survey.

ISI versus GS score for journals

CategoryJournal NameISI Impact FactorGS Impact Factor
A* Journal of the ACM2.935
B Pattern Analysis Applications0.48
A* Transactions on Knowledge and Data Engineering2.115
A Information Retrieal1.79.5
A* Artificial Intelligence2.322
B AI EDAM0.45
A Computational Intelligence1.49
A* IEEE Trans. on Pattern Analysis and Machine Intelligence4.334
B AI Communications0.54
A AI in Medicine1.612
B International Journal of Pattern Recognition0.54
A Decision Support Systems1.217.5
A* Machine Learning2.632.5
A* International Journal of Computer Vision627
A Data and Knowledge Engineering1.48

Table of Acceptance Rates

These are the available Acceptance rates and their sources. These acceptance rates were used to generate the scatterplot below. If you have further acceptance rates please send them to us and we will include them in our Scatterplot.

ConferenceAcceptance RateNumber Of SubmissionsNumber of Accepted PapersNotesSource
UAI 20000.3684.030http://www.adaptivebox.net/CILib/CICON_stat.html#UAI
UAI 20010.484.00no figures for the number of accepted papers quotedhttp://www.adaptivebox.net/CILib/CICON_stat.html#UAI
UAI 20020.34192.066http://www.adaptivebox.net/CILib/CICON_stat.html#UAI
UAI 20030.336229.07725 papers accepted for oral presentation (10.9% acceptance rate) & 52 accepted for poster presentationhttp://www.adaptivebox.net/CILib/CICON_stat.html#UAI
ECAI 20020.277505.0140from Pádraig Cunningham
NIPS 20010.302650.0196http://www.adaptivebox.net/CILib/CICON_stat.html#NIPS
ECAI 20000.314443.0139from Pádraig Cunningham
NIPS 20030.276717.0198http://www.adaptivebox.net/CILib/CICON_stat.html#NIPS
AAAI 20000.332431.0143http://www.aaai.org/Conferences/AAAI/aaai.php
AAAI 20020.258469.0121http://www.aaai.org/Conferences/AAAI/aaai.php
ECCV 20020.379600.022645 papers accepted for oral presentation (7.5% acceptance rate) & 181 accepted for poster presentation (30.2% poster acceptance rate)http://www.adaptivebox.net/CILib/CICON_stat.html#ECCV
ICML 20010.321249.080http://www.adaptivebox.net/CILib/CICON_stat.html#ICML
ICML 20000.443349.0151http://www.adaptivebox.net/CILib/CICON_stat.html#ICML
ICML 20030.321371.0119http://www.adaptivebox.net/CILib/CICON_stat.html#ICML
ICML 20020.33261.086http://www.adaptivebox.net/CILib/CICON_stat.html#ICML
IJCAI 20010.25796.0197http://www.adaptivebox.net/CILib/CICON_stat.html#IJCAI
IJCAI 20030.207913.0189189(regular= 20.7%) **63(poster)**http://www.adaptivebox.net/CILib/CICON_stat.html#IJCAI
ECML 20010.375240.050The acceptance rate quoted here is calculated on pkdd/ecml where 90 papers were submitted. However our database only contains 50 papers. This acceptance rate is therefore an approximation (90 from 240) from the combined figures for ECML/PKDD from Pádraig Cunningham
ECML 20000.43100.04343 papers accepted (20 + 23) from 100 from Pádraig Cunningham
NIPS 20020.311710.0221http://www.adaptivebox.net/CILib/CICON_stat.html#NIPS
ECCBR 20020.70364.04564 submissions (18+5+14+8) acceptedfrom a mail from Susan Craw to Pádraig Cunningham
GECCO 20030.686417.0286194 papers accepted for oral presentation (46.5% acceptance rate) & 92 accepted for poster presentationhttp://www.adaptivebox.net/CILib/CICON_stat.html#GECCO
ICCBR 20030.55492.05151(19+32) from 92from Pádraig Cunningham

Paper conference/type Breakdown

This table shows a breakdown of how many papers of each type are in the database for each conference.

ConferenceTypeNumber Of PapersGS Impact Factor
AAAI 2000Application Paper189
AAAI 2000DC Paper100
AAAI 2000Demo Paper122.5
AAAI 2000Invited Paper84
AAAI 2000Robot Competition and Exibition Paper1None
AAAI 2000Student Abstract Paper360
AAAI 2000Technical Paper14324.5
AAAI 2002Application Paper1810.5
AAAI 2002DC Paper130
AAAI 2002Demo Paper100
AAAI 2002Invited Paper20
AAAI 2002Student Abstract Paper174
AAAI 2002Technical Paper12014
AH 2000DC Paper43.5
AH 2000Full Paper2219.5
AH 2000Invited Paper13
AH 2000Short Paper315
AH 2002Full Paper3316
AH 2002Invited Paper333
AH 2002Poster Paper353
AH 2002Short Paper233
COLING 2000Not Specified17410
COLING 2002Not Specified1988
ECAI 2000Not Specified1419
ECAI 2002Not Specified1406
ECCV 2000Not Specified11611.5
ECCV 2002Not Specified22616
ECML 2000Full Paper436
ECML 2000Invited Paper218
ECML 2001Full Paper5010.5
ECML 2001Invited Paper52
ECML 2002Full Paper417
ECML 2002Invited Paper419
ECML 2003Full Paper405
ECML 2003Invited Paper41
ECCBR 2000Application Paper166.5
ECCBR 2000Invited Paper24
ECCBR 2000Research Paper2611.5
ECCBR 2002Application Paper144.5
ECCBR 2002Invited Paper28.5
ECCBR 2002Research Paper318
GECCO 2000Full Paper1199
GECCO 2000Poster Paper633
GECCO 2002Not Specified2306
GECCO 2003Full Paper2005
GECCO 2003Poster Paper852
ICANN 2001Invited Paper36.5
ICANN 2001Not Specified1713
ICANN 2002Not Specified2213
ICANN 2003Not Specified1402
ICCBR 2001Application Paper144.5
ICCBR 2001Invited Paper314
ICCBR 2001Research Paper3613.5
ICCBR 2003Full Paper514
ICCBR 2003Invited Paper30.5
ICML 2000Not Specified15015
ICML 2001Not Specified8016
ICML 2002Not Specified8711
ICML 2003Not Specified11614
IJCAI 2001Invited Paper35
IJCAI 2001Not Specified19620
IJCAI 2003Computers and Thought Award Paper129
IJCAI 2003Full Paper18915
IJCAI 2003Intelligent Systems Demonstrations90
IJCAI 2003Invited Speakers1016.5
IJCAI 2003Poster Paper873
NIPS 2000Not Specified15314
NIPS 2001Not Specified19613
NIPS 2002Not Specified20713
NIPS 2003Not Specified1989.5
TREC 2000Not Specified7410
TREC 2001Not Specified8410
TREC 2002Not Specified1006
TREC 2003Not Specified1006
UAI 2000Not Specified7517
UAI 2001Not Specified7111
UAI 2002Not Specified6916
UAI 2003Not Specified7710

Scatterplot of Available Rejection Rates versus GS scores

Here is the headline result of conference rejection rate (1 - acceptance rate) against GS score

Scatterplot of Available Rejection Rates versus GS scores
ConferenceRejection RateGS score
UAI 20000.6417.00
UAI 20010.6011.00
UAI 20020.6616.00
UAI 20030.6610.00
ECAI 20020.726.00
NIPS 20010.7013.00
ECAI 20000.699.00
NIPS 20030.729.50
AAAI 20000.6724.50
AAAI 20020.7414.00
ECCV 20020.6216.00
ICML 20010.6816.00
ICML 20000.5615.00
ICML 20030.6814.00
ICML 20020.6711.00
IJCAI 20010.7520.00
IJCAI 20030.7915.00
ECML 20010.6210.50
ECML 20000.576.00
NIPS 20020.6913.00
ECCBR 20020.307.00
GECCO 20030.314.00
ICCBR 20030.454.00

Cross correlation is 0.532503

GS Impact Factor per Venue for Each Year

This table shows a breakdown of the GS Impact factor of each venue per year.

Venue2000200120022003GS Impact Factor
TKDE2314151415
PE911958.5
PAMI4332362634
PAA118978
ML35.532362932.5
JACM32.55951.524.535
IR1586.559.5
INFFUS1010.5106.59
IJPRAI45.5534
IJCV36.513.5272127
DSS1718181717.5
DKE1010.5868
CI7.58179
ARTMED159.51012.512
AIEDAM54635
AICOM1.547.52.54
AI272222.51722
UAI1711161013
TREC1010668
NIPS1413139.512
IJCAI201517
ICML1516111414
ICCBR946
ICANN3323
GECCO7645
ECCBR878
ECML610.5757
ECCV11.51613.5
ECAI967
COLING1089
AH19.51617
AAAI24.51420

International versus Local Venues

This table shows a breakdown of the GS Impact Factor of International versus local (European) conferences.

YearICMLECML
2000156
20011610.5
2002117
2003145
YearAAAIECAI
200024.59
2001NoneNone
2002146
2003NoneNone
YearICCBRECCBR
2000None8
20019None
2002None7
20034None

Open versus Closed World Venues?

This table shows a breakdown of the GS Impact Factor count of ECCBR (formally known as EWCBR) versus ECAI.

YearECCBRECAI
200089
2001NoneNone
200276
2003NoneNone